Updated 23 October 2026
What each part does
The battery stores energy. Its main job is to turn the starter motor and to keep the car's electronics alive while the engine is off. The alternator makes energy. Once the engine is running it powers the car and recharges the battery.
So the two fail in different ways. A failing battery usually shows itself when the engine is off or starting. A failing alternator usually shows itself while the engine is running, because the car slowly uses up what is left in the battery. The third possibility, a parasitic drain, is something that keeps drawing current after the car is locked, and it flattens a perfectly good battery overnight or over a few days.
Symptoms that point one way or the other
| Symptom | Points towards | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Slow crank or clicking in the morning, then fine after a jump and a drive | Battery | It can no longer hold enough charge, or has lost capacity to heat and age. |
| Starts fine, then dies while driving | Alternator | The car is running on battery alone and has used it up. |
| Battery warning light on while the engine is running | Alternator or charging circuit | The car has detected the system is not charging. The light is a charging warning, not a battery-health warning. |
| Headlights dim at idle and brighten when you rev the engine | Alternator or drive belt | Output is weak at low engine speed. |
| Flat after being parked for a few days, fine with daily use | Parasitic drain, or an old battery | Something is drawing current while parked, or the battery has too little reserve to cover normal standby use. |
| Needs a jump twice in one week | Battery or a drain — test both | A healthy battery and charging system do not do this. |
| Whining noise that rises with engine speed, or a burning smell | Alternator | Worn bearings or an overheating unit. |
| Swollen case, leaking or a rotten-egg smell | Battery | Physical damage, often from heat or overcharging. Do not jump it. |
If the battery warning light comes on while you are driving, the car is living on stored charge. Switch off what you do not need, such as the rear demister and seat heaters, and get somewhere safe before it stops.
The voltage readings to expect
A basic multimeter set to DC volts, red probe on the positive terminal and black on the negative, gives a useful first picture. The figures below are the widely used approximate guides for a standard 12V lead-acid battery. Exact values vary by battery type and temperature, and AGM batteries tend to read a little higher at rest.
| When you measure | Roughly what you should see | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Engine off, rested for several hours | About 12.6V or a little above | A fully charged battery. |
| Engine off, rested | About 12.4V | Partly discharged. Worth charging and testing. |
| Engine off, rested | About 12.0V or below | Badly discharged. It may still start the car, but it will not last. |
| Engine running, lights and AC off | Roughly 13.5V to 14.7V | The alternator is charging normally. |
| Engine running | At or below the resting figure | Not charging. Suspect the alternator, belt or wiring. |
| Engine running | Well above about 15V | Overcharging, which damages batteries. Have the charging system checked. |
Why a voltmeter alone can mislead
Voltage tells you the state of charge. It does not tell you whether the battery can deliver current when the starter asks for it. That difference is what catches most people out.
Surface charge
Straight after driving or charging, a battery shows a higher voltage than it can really sustain. This is surface charge, and it fades over a few hours. A battery that reads 12.7V just after a drive can be back below 12.3V by the next morning. That is why the resting reading should be taken after the car has stood for several hours, or after switching the headlights on for a minute to clear it.
Load versus no load
A battery that has lost capacity can show a healthy-looking 12.6V with nothing connected, then collapse as soon as the starter draws a few hundred amps. The only way to see this is to test under load. A proper battery tester applies a load or measures internal resistance and reports the battery's real cranking ability against its rated CCA. As a broad rule of thumb, if the voltage drops below roughly 9.6V while the engine is cranking, the battery is struggling.
A battery can hide an alternator fault, and the reverse
A new battery will mask a weak alternator for a few days, until it too runs down. A badly sulphated battery can make a healthy alternator look weak, because the alternator is working flat out trying to charge a battery that will not accept it. Testing both together is what avoids the wrong diagnosis.
Smart alternators on European cars
Many European and premium cars, and an increasing number of others, run a smart alternator controlled by the engine computer and an intelligent battery sensor. To save fuel, it charges hard when the car is coasting or braking and backs off when you accelerate or cruise. On these cars it is normal to see a running voltage well below 13.5V at times, sometimes close to the battery's resting voltage, by design rather than as a fault.
This catches out many people, and some fitters, who measure the voltage at idle, see a low figure and condemn a working alternator. On these cars the charging system has to be read through the diagnostic tool, which shows what the car is asking the alternator to do. These cars also need the new battery registered so that the charging strategy matches it — something our homepage explains in more detail.
A simple order of checks
- Look at the battery: case, terminals, corrosion, and the date on the label.
- Measure the resting voltage after the car has stood for a few hours.
- Start the engine and measure again with the lights and AC off.
- Turn on the headlights, AC fan and rear demister and see whether the running voltage holds.
- If the battery keeps going flat while parked, measure the current draw with the car locked and asleep — this is a parasitic drain test.
- Have the battery load-tested before buying anything.
The first four take a cheap multimeter and ten minutes. The last two need a battery tester and a clamp meter, and some experience with how long modern cars take to go to sleep after locking.
When it is neither
Sometimes the battery tests well and the alternator charges correctly, and the car still has trouble. Loose or corroded terminals, a worn earth strap, a faulty starter motor, or a dash camera or tracker wired to run permanently can all produce symptoms that look like a battery fault. In those cases the fix is in the wiring or the starter, and a new battery would not have helped.
This is the reason we test before we sell. Our battery and charging-system testing in Dubai Creek Harbour covers the four checks: state of charge, cranking amps under load, alternator output and parasitic drain. If the battery is fine, we tell you plainly and the diagnosis costs nothing. If the problem is the alternator or the starter, we say so, and you can take that to a workshop — see our garage services page for the other work available in Dubai Creek Harbour. You can also see the full diagnostics service on our homepage.


